Among 284,436 Swedish men followed from ages 45-54 into their late 60s, those in physically demanding jobs faced a 34% higher risk of incident ischaemic heart disease and a 93% higher risk of IHD death than men in low-workload jobs. Adjusting for youth socioeconomic position, BMI, blood pressure and education shrank the incidence hazard ratio to 1.06 but left IHD mortality at 1.38. Men with low youth fitness and a heavy-workload job carried the highest risk, though the additive interaction was not statistically significant.
The near-vanishing of the incidence effect after adjustment is the key detail: most of the crude signal reflects who ends up in manual labour, not what the work does to the heart. The surviving mortality excess is more credible, and fits the 'physical activity paradox' literature, where occupational activity lacks the cardiovascular benefits of leisure-time exercise, likely because it is prolonged, low-intensity, lacks recovery, and often coexists with shift work, stress and low job control. Limitations matter. Workload came from a job exposure matrix, which assigns exposure by occupation rather than individual measurement, and fitness was measured only in youth, decades before outcomes. The cohort is men only, and residual confounding from smoking and diet is likely. For readers, the practical message is modest but sound: a physically demanding job does not substitute for building fitness through structured leisure exercise, and good youth fitness appears partly protective. Confirmatory rather than paradigm-shifting, but its size and follow-up strengthen the case for workplace interventions.